James Harrison, Dirty Hits, the Media, Roger Goodell and NFL Safety

Things I learned this week: football is violent. I also learned that people, in general, are dumb. The media-generated backlash from a weekend full of helmet-to-helmet hits has had basically the same effect Karl Rove’s media machine had on unsuspecting dipshits during the first half of George W. Bush’s administration.

I’m not trying to turn this into a political discussion and, frankly, I don’t care if you’re Republican, Democrat, Tea Party or Whig. Here’s my point: sometimes folks grab a pitchfork and join the mob without considering exactly what it is they’re railing against. And that’s exactly what happened after a handful of “holy shit” helmet-to-helmet collisions in Week 6.

So, naturally, the first order of business was to blow everything out of proportion and act as if it’s just now dawned on us that, you know, football is violent. And once that was established, it was only logical to conclude that suspensions for repeat, flagrant offenders would be the only suitable solution. To send them the message that helmet-to-helmet hits won’t be tolerated.

(By the way, it’s gotten to the point that I don’t even know what the rules are. If James Harrison had been flagged for both the Cribbs and Massaquoi hits I wouldn’t have been surprised or upset. But the NFL’s Greg Aiello said after the game that the Cribbs hit was legal, although the Massquoi hit was being reviewed. And if it turns out that Harrison is a little lighter in the wallet for the latter, that’s fine too. Officials have flagged similar-looking plays before. But let’s not make him out to be a serial killer. Whether you want to admit it or not, the NFL markets violence because people like it. Just pointing out what should already be obvious but clearly isn’t.)

This isn’t a diatribe against keeping guys safe. It’s a diatribe against faulty logic and overreactions. Helmet-to-helmet hits have been a part of football, well, forever. Rodney Harrison was suspended eight years ago for a helmet-to-helmet hit against Jerry Rice. And you know what? When he returned from suspension he was still a dirty player who still got fined for — you guessed it — dirty hits.

And that leads me to this: where’s the research that suggests that suspending players is some kind of long-term deterrent? I mean, if we’re serious about player safety and removing these types of plays from the game, shouldn’t we have some notion about whether a punishment works before we proclaim that we’re serious about it?

Not only that, Roger Goodell’s doesn’t have the best track record when it comes to punishments fitting the crime. If anything, his approach can best be described at haphazard. That might make for good PR (“He’s coming down hard on offenders!”) but again, there’s no proof that randomly assigning punishments actually reduces crime. Isn’t that sorta the point?

And while I’ve heard countless times in the past few days that nobody cares more about player safety than Goodell, I have a hard time reconciling that with the fact that an 18-game schedule seems very likely in 2012.

Here’s Goodell in August: “We want to do it the right way for everyone, including the players, the fans and the game in general,” Goodell said. “There’s a tremendous amount of momentum for [an 18-game schedule]. We think it’s the right step.”

If this is the champion for safety, the players are in deep shit. Let me know when Goodell and the NFL quit talking out of both sides of their mouth.

This entry was posted in 2010 steelers and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://www.steelerslounge.com/ ryan

    …and according to Mort, Deebo has been fined $75,000. Brandon Meriweather got a $50K fine but Harrison got more for repeat offenses. I have no recollection of previous Deebo helmet-to-helmet hits. (Maybe they’re talking about the Cribbs hit.) Anybody else remember anything?

    • eddie

      the vince young fine from earlier this year…

      • http://www.steelerslounge.com/ ryan

        Does that count? Or is it just helmet to helmet? Because the VY fine was $5k. Now the Massquoi fine is 15 times that? Makes sense and sure to solve the problem.

  • RoB D

    Goodell WOULD be the worst commissioner in American sports if not for Gary Bettman but he’s closing fast. He changes the rules, has no process, and now overreacts to a few hard shots in games this weekend. Excuse me, I have to go watch NFLN’s “10 Greatest Hits of All Time”. I don’t think Sabol flinches when he puts those together. He seems to think help to win games. And the NFL and NFL films are kinda joined at the hip..a popular propaganda arm for the NFL. Hypocrisy, thy name is Roger and Co.

    Why is Favre not suspended already, BTW? He’s got no formal charges against him (ala BB), the evidence is spotty/shaky (is that really his..ahem), and the complainant doesn’t seem to be complaining or wanting to press charges. Sounds like an open and shut case in Roger’s little bubble. But wait! It’s Brett freaking Favre ..the family man..the greatest QB in all of history…so ..we have to look at the evidence till the season is over apparently.

    I am overrunning with bile. so I’ll stop here.

  • Dave

    “I believe the game is designed to reward the ones who hit the hardest. If you can’t take it, you shouldn’t play.” Jack Lambert.

  • Anonymous

    The leaders of this crusade – the sports media – can solve this themselves.

    Any team whose defensive players do these dstardly deeds should be dropped three to ten places in the PowerRankings, depending on the severity of the offense.

    Try that, Peter King. That will show them!!

  • Will S

    Agreed with everything above – Roger Goodell couldn’t manage his way out of a wet paper bag. Management 101 is consistency in actions, and Goodell is as capricious as a schoolgirl. What’s more, he’s also the inventor of the poorly written NFL Personal Conduct Policy, so the buck stops with him.

  • http://www.steelerslounge.com/ ryan

    It keeps getting better. Headline from Yahoo’s Shutdown Corner:“NFL.com selling pictures of Harrison and Meriweather hits”Makes sense.

  • Pingback: NFL Unveils Plan to Teach James Harrison Proper Technique | Steelers Lounge

  • eyespy

    I wonder what these pearl-clutchers think about us drone-bombing anything that moves on the Pakistani border.

    James Harrison is a violent psychopath.

    Which is why he’s so freaking good at his job.

    He could have been a little more circumspect about it, but that’s the only crime here.

    The hypocrisy is truly outrageous.

  • Hamm

    Goodell is nothing more than a puny turd with an ax to grind in his dreams of self-aggrandizement. But if that’s what the league wants or puts up with, who are we mere human fans to question his divinity? He didn’t just blow a call, he blew his way all the to the top.

  • Pingback: Steelers Prepare for Ravens in Week 13 Matchup | Steelers Lounge

  • Pingback: Goodell, 18-Game Schedules and Steelers Pass Defense | Steelers Lounge